Friday, March 2, 2012

"Incarnate" by Jodi Meadows - Review

Where have I been?
I'm not entirely sure. See, I've been working and editing... and... well that's all I can remember O_O Oh! Yes! I've also been reading!


I started a fantasy book that I decided 3/4's of the way through - sucked. So, while I was looking for a birthday present for my husband at Chapters the other day (where else would I look?), I glanced around for a book to read. To my dismay, all I saw were.... fairy, vampire and werewolf books. *Sigh* I think my generation doesn't have good taste in books. Not that I have anything against paranormal books, but the obsession that goes along with them doesn't sit well with me.
Then! I remembered... "What was that book...? That one I read about on the author's blog...?... Ah-ha!"


And that, my friends, is how I bought "Incarnate" by Jodi Meadows.

 Synopsis:
Ana is the first "newsoul" to be born in Range. For thousands of years people have lived, died, and been born again while keeping the memories from their previous lives. Ana, however, replaced someone. She was never supposed to be born. Her mother hates her and many are afraid there will be more like her that will replace old souls.
At 18 she travels to Heart, the city where most of the population of Range lives. Along the way she is rescued from drowning by Sam, a music composer. His body is around the same ages as hers but he has lived and died hundreds of times.
He watches out for her and takes her to Heart with him. There, Ana searches for the reason for her existence.
The counsel, however, isn't as eager as Sam is to receive her and she is subjected to their rules. They claim it is for her safety and benefit. But she asks too many questions about things others think she shouldn't. She finds herself in danger of being killed. Ana and Sam form a strong attachment through music which quickly becomes much more.



What I liked:
It was unique. I'd never read a fantasy book about reincarnation before. The book kept me engaged all the way through.
I liked that Ana accepted help from Sam. Most female characters tend to try to be too tough and it's hard for me to relate to them when I am frustrated with them every time they get into a conversation with their romantic interest. Ana, however, had a nice balance of independence while still relying on others. Her character development was well paced.
The imagery in the book was also quite good. Imagery is something that I have always found hard to write but Jodi Meadows had enough description to give me a vivid picture in my head without overwhelming with details.
The book is well written.


What I Didn't Like:
I appreciated the idea that a soul isn't defined by it's gender but I wasn't a fan of the idea that people's souls were reincarnated into both male and female bodies, depending on the life-time.
Sam and Ana make some suggestive comments to each other near in the latter half of the book. In my opinion, books for teens have far too much of that these days. “Intimate” scenes are uncalled for, especially in books for teen girls (I ought to know, I'm still one myself). I prefer to read and suggest a book to friends without being uncomfortable about parts in it. I returned "The Graceling" by Kristin Cashore to Chapters for that very reason and ranted to my friends about how annoyed I was.


Verdict:
Over-all, I liked “Incarnate” and look forward to the sequel!

3 comments:

  1. Thank you for the comment on my blog! :) I think what your pastor said was very interesting...it's quite true!

    I think you're quite right...our generation has horrible book tastes. Not only that, but most of the writers in this day and age really should quit writing, because they have nothing good to say! Especially on the 'fairy, werewolf and vampire' subject. I always either laugh to my death or get realllly angry when I see a teenage girl with the shirt that reads: "I (heart) Vampires". <- that is beyond supidity. I mean, come on, they can only be villains!

    By the way, I think I have heard of this book before...or seen it somewhere. I'm always looking for books that have been very well written, so that I can become a better writer myself. Would you suggest Incarnate by Jodi Meadows? Any other suggestions would be nice too :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for commenting on mine too :)
      I am going to be periodically doing book reviews. If you follow my blog you might find some that interest you. But, off the top of my head, my all-time favourite books are:

      Where the Red Fern Grows – Wilson Rawls
      Inkheart - Cornelia Funke
      Dragon Keeper Cronicles - Donita K. Paul
      They Loved to Laugh - Kathryn Worth
      Ender's Game - Orson Scott Card
      Also, many of the books by Lloyd Alexander

      I hope that gives you something to read!

      Delete
  2. Me too, I'll see if I can find any of them from the library :) Thanks!!! :)

    ReplyDelete